The Memory Wars: Freud's Legacy in Dispute by Frederick Crews

By Frederick Crews

The famous gadfly literary scholar's debatable critique of Freudianism within the overdue twentieth century, and its impression at the recovered reminiscence stream.

From Wikipedia:

The results of an issue within the big apple overview of Books, The reminiscence Wars comprises essays and letters to the editor that first seemed within the evaluate in 1993 and 1994. while the overview released "The Unknown Freud," an essay reviewing a number of books approximately Freud and psychoanalysis, it acquired many letters of protest, to which Crews responded. 12 months later, the evaluation released "The Revenge of the Repressed," a critique of "recovered reminiscence therapy," whose practitioners declare to aid sufferers repair repressed, occasionally terrible, stories of kid abuse. extra letters criticizing Crews have been released, and Crews answered to them additionally. as well as "The Unknown Freud" and "The Revenge of the Repressed," the letters in reaction and Crews's replies to them, The reminiscence Wars includes an creation and an afterword by way of Crews. He argues that Freud used to be not just unscientific in his tools, yet a charlatan who browbeat his sufferers, falsified his findings, tyrannized his fans, and cheated on his spouse. Crews's place was once summarized as, "psychoanalysis is a spurious, useless pseudoscience, in line with the fudged info of an unscrupulous and calculating founder and perpetuated by means of fans who mimic his craftiness in a 'shell video game wherein critics of Freudianism are constantly instructed that new breakthroughs render their strictures obsolete.'" Crews sees the recovered reminiscence stream because the latest, and most deadly, improvement of Freud's principles.

Show description

Read Online or Download The Memory Wars: Freud's Legacy in Dispute PDF

Best film books

Cinema and Spectatorship (Sightlines)

Cinema and Spectatorship is the 1st ebook to concentration completely at the heritage and position of the spectator in modern movie experiences. whereas Seventies movie thought insisted on a contrast betweeen the cinematic topic and film-goers, Judith Mayne means that a truly actual friction among "subjects" and "viewers" is in reality principal to the examine of spectatorship.

Bride of Frankenstein (Movie Monsters Series)

Whereas the wounded and anxious Monster he created spreads terror through the kingdom aspect, Dr. Frankenstein is persuaded by way of a colleague to create a girl to be the Monster's bride.

Leonard Maltin's Family Movie Guide

Well-known as one of many top professionals on American movie, Leonard Maltin can also be a guardian who's conscious of the variations among a child's and critic's point of view on motion pictures. every one movie indexed contains its MPAA score, a proof of that score, classification, and the author's personal ranking method of even if a movie is sweet, undesirable, or ok for either older and more youthful childrens.

Knockout: The Boxer and Boxing in American Cinema

Knockout: The Boxer and Boxing in American Cinema is the 1st book-length learn of the Hollywood boxing movie, a favored motion picture leisure because the Nineteen Thirties, that comes with such classics as "Million greenback Baby," "Rocky," and "Raging Bull. " The boxer stands along the cowboy, the gangster, and the detective as a personality that formed America's principles of manhood.

Extra resources for The Memory Wars: Freud's Legacy in Dispute

Example text

Tl miseunstructitms and its pathetic outcome. to l:reutl'_s normal practice. For a concise sense of that relation. readers can consult an important l‘)‘)l article h_\' lirank Sulln\\'a_\' that reviews all of the maior caschistnries aml infers that the_\' cuinposc a uniform picture all liircetl interptetatiun. imliliisrent nr negative therapeutic results. " We can go lilrther and ask whether. strictly speaking. lireutl can be said to have ever practiced psycl1oat1;thx\is in the sense that he commemled tu others.

That "provisionally" infantilizes its clients in the interest olireeovering early material whose repression or dissociation allegedly made them ill. But this is simply a characterization of the classical Freudian program. 1 single one of the named criteria. Let us suppose. nally. that the "retrautnatizing_" of pS_\'Cl1U£lllLll_\'$l5I by means olia revived seduction theory is only an ephemeral threat alter all. The lact remains that psychoanalysis and lt:\|'l‘ are profoundly alike and that their reseml hlance is anything but lorttiitotis.

Except from a public relations angle. whether those patients improved as a result ofhis treatment. As he sarcasrically wrote to Carl ‘lung in 1‘) l Z about a woman who had heen in and out ofhis care since I908. "she is beyond any possibility of therapy. “ Frink. it this instance to Freud's seems. also had to he sacriced-in working capital rather than to his intellectual passions. What the Ecksrein and Frink episodes have most in common is a perfect match between Freudis diagnoses and his immediate selflinrerest.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.39 of 5 – based on 8 votes